Room 313

adventures in teaching creative writing

REVIEW: Book Love

Penny Kittle walks the walk. Not only does she spread a love of reading in her classrooms, she lets books invade her life outside the classroom as well. Whether it’s on a family trip to the British Isles or in an airport, waiting for a flight, Penny can be found reading. She knows that good reading teachers–even at the high school level–must read lots of books if they are to recommend them to their students. Let that sink in. If you are a high school English teacher like me, think: how many of your colleagues are voracious readers?

In Book Love, Kittle explains her rationale for the reading program she has developed for her high school English classroom. She defends her choices to prepare her students for college with young adult literature in the face of Common Core standards. She shares success stories about students, and shares tips on challenging her students to become deeper, more sophisticated readers likes using goals, reflections, conferences, and close readings. Her love for her students, for reading, and for the English teacher professional is infectious, and I found myself cheering her along.

Great quotes:
“A book isn’t rigorous if students aren’t reading it.” (xvi)
“Voluminous, voracious readers are our only hope.” (23)
“This is the calling of an English teacher for me: give each student books that teach them, challenge them, and lead them to places they’ll never know otherwise” (44).
“People will tell you there is no time for fun in today’s classroom. They will say that very seriously. Don’t buy it.” (73)
“We can’t teach something we don’t practice.” (158)

Only a few times did this book not work for me. Kittle uses different castle doors as metaphors for different book genres in Chapter 4, which was a little too cutesy. Also, a few times in the book, she mentioned different items (book lists, for example) were available on her website. Why not just make them available in the book? Or if that’s not possible, include a QR code to quickly leap to the website! The cool-sounding literature map on page 122 is not described in detail, and no picture of it is included in the book or online. Finally, Kittle’s example of a book talk on pages 61-62 was for Why We Broke Up, one of my least favorite YA books in recent memory, and Kittle seems to adore it. Of course, everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, but her positive review of WWBU kind of bothered me.

Overall, though, this is a tremendous book on making reading real in the high school English classroom. I will return to it throughout my career. Thanks, Penny. I felt the love.

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

3 thoughts on “REVIEW: Book Love

  1. Thanks for the review, Jason. I’ve been looking forward to reading this, and your honest review is helpful in pushing it towards the top of my To-Read list.

  2. tamaraeden on said:

    Thanks for this. I have SO MANY pedagogy books that I will likely never read. I hate them. However, knowing there is a book that is actually a good tool out there will make me more likely to check it out the next time at at B&N.

  3. Jason your statement about how many teachers actually read (“how many of your colleagues are voracious readers?”) spoke to me. When I joined the profession, I assumed (and we know what happens when you assume…) that all educators were readers. I have been saddened by the fact that the majority of my collegues don’t read at all. I assumed that all educators were basically frustrated students, and that all teachers loved to continue their personal education. I also assumed that this continued education included reading. I still maintain that most learning occurs through a natural love of a subject. For me that love becomes interest, which becomes reading about what I’m interested about. Don’t get me wrong, I also love to obtain knowledge through documentaries too. It is sad when our librarian can’t even get teachers to recommend books because the teachers don’t read. This saddens me. I think all educators should be voracious readers. It should be a prerequisite to the job. I will now step off my soapbox. I’m sorry. I’m having a bad day so I have lashed out.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: